Difference between revisions of "Tomato Processing by Solar Energy"

From energypedia
***** (***** | *****)
***** (***** | *****)
m
 
(21 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
 +
Economic development in remote rural areas in [[Ethiopia Energy Situation|Ethiopia]] can be enhanced by value adding on farmers’ agricultural raw products. Small scale agro processing must lead to consumable end products, which are food safe, conservable, transportable and marketable. The following case presents an example of how [[Solar Energy|Solar Energy]] can support micro and small tomato processing enterprises in [[Ethiopia Energy Situation|Ethiopia]]. This article is a fact sheet, for more details please see the article [[Business Plan for Solar Processing of Tomatoes|Business Plan for Solar Processing of Tomatoes]].<br/>
  
Economic development in remote rural areas in Ethiopia can be enhanced by value adding on farmers’ agricultural raw products. Small scale agro processing must lead to consumable end products, which are food safe, conservable, transportable and marketable. The following case presents an example of how solar energy can support micro and small tomato processing enterprises in Ethiopia. This article is a fact sheet, for more details please see the article [[Business Plan for Solar Processing of Tomatoes|Business Plan for Solar Processing of Tomatoes]].
 
  
 
= Project =
 
= Project =
 
 
TAMPA (Tigray Agricultural Marketing Promotion Agency) started in April 2014 in collaboration with the Sustainable Land Management Program (GIZ SLMP) the promotion of micro and small enterprises for tomato processing using renewable energy. The target groups are cooperatives of tomato farmers producing in remote areas without access to electrical power (2014: only 14% of the Ethiopian population has access to grid power, see also [[Ethiopia Energy Situation|Ethiopia Energy Situation]]).
 
TAMPA (Tigray Agricultural Marketing Promotion Agency) started in April 2014 in collaboration with the Sustainable Land Management Program (GIZ SLMP) the promotion of micro and small enterprises for tomato processing using renewable energy. The target groups are cooperatives of tomato farmers producing in remote areas without access to electrical power (2014: only 14% of the Ethiopian population has access to grid power, see also [[Ethiopia Energy Situation|Ethiopia Energy Situation]]).
  
Line 9: Line 8:
  
 
The end products are tomato paste/sauce, tomato juice, dried tomatoes and tomato powder. These are conservable without cooling (paste 6 months, juice 1 month, dried tomatoes/powder up to 1 year) and allow the producers to receive better prices for their commercial products:
 
The end products are tomato paste/sauce, tomato juice, dried tomatoes and tomato powder. These are conservable without cooling (paste 6 months, juice 1 month, dried tomatoes/powder up to 1 year) and allow the producers to receive better prices for their commercial products:
 +
 +
 
*3,150 kg of fresh tomatoes are processed to 1,260 kg long conservable tomato paste, packed into 3,150 bags of each 200 gram plus 1,260 bags of 500g
 
*3,150 kg of fresh tomatoes are processed to 1,260 kg long conservable tomato paste, packed into 3,150 bags of each 200 gram plus 1,260 bags of 500g
 
*1,050 kg of fresh tomatoes are processed to 735 liter of tomato juice, packed in 1,470 bottles (‘Highland’) of each 0.5 liters
 
*1,050 kg of fresh tomatoes are processed to 735 liter of tomato juice, packed in 1,470 bottles (‘Highland’) of each 0.5 liters
 
*5,000 kg of fresh tomatoes will be sun-dried to 675 kg dried tomato slices, and 75 kg tomato powder, packed into vacuum-sealed polyethylene bags
 
*5,000 kg of fresh tomatoes will be sun-dried to 675 kg dried tomato slices, and 75 kg tomato powder, packed into vacuum-sealed polyethylene bags
 +
''Please note:'' The solar system is all year around available and can be used for other income generating activities, like television, video, lighting, battery charging, water cooking, sterilization, other food processing, office services like scan/print/internet/email…
  
''Please note:'' The solar system is all year around available and can be used for other income generating activities, like television, video, lighting, battery charging, water cooking, sterilization, other food processing, office services like scan/print/internet/email…
 
  
 
= Technology =
 
= Technology =
 
 
A room of 16 m2 should be sufficient as processing site. It will be built by the farmers’ men power contribution, stones are available onsite and construction material like cement, metal sheets for the roof and a metal door/window as well as tiles will be supplied by the GIZ SLM Program.
 
A room of 16 m2 should be sufficient as processing site. It will be built by the farmers’ men power contribution, stones are available onsite and construction material like cement, metal sheets for the roof and a metal door/window as well as tiles will be supplied by the GIZ SLM Program.
  
Line 23: Line 23:
 
Special attention will be given to train the processing team in technical aspects of the photovoltaic power system. This includes the handling of the precious inverter, the regular cleaning of the panel and the maintenance of the acid batteries.
 
Special attention will be given to train the processing team in technical aspects of the photovoltaic power system. This includes the handling of the precious inverter, the regular cleaning of the panel and the maintenance of the acid batteries.
  
{| align="center" style="width: 750px" border="0" cellspacing="1" cellpadding="5"
+
 
 +
{| align="center" style="width: 750px;" border="0" cellspacing="1" cellpadding="5"
 
|-
 
|-
| [[File:Solar Mirror Processing of Tomatoes.jpg|248px|Solar reflector used for tomato processing © TAMPA|alt=Solar reflector used for tomato processing © TAMPA]]<br/>
+
| [[File:Solar Mirror Processing of Tomatoes.jpg|248px|Solar reflector used for tomato processing © TAMPA|alt=Solar reflector used for tomato processing © TAMPA]]
| [[File:Solar Processing of Tomatoes in Tembien.jpg|248px|Processing of tomatoes in Tembien © TAMPA|alt=Processing of tomatoes in Tembien © TAMPA]]<br/>
+
| [[File:Solar Processing of Tomatoes in Tembien.jpg|248px|Processing of tomatoes in Tembien © TAMPA|alt=Processing of tomatoes in Tembien © TAMPA]]
| [[File:Packed Tomato Paste PET-Bags.gif|208px|Tomato paste sterile packed into PET-bags © TAMPA|alt=Tomato paste, sterile packed into PET-bags © TAMPA]]<br/>
+
| [[File:Packed Tomato Paste PET-Bags.gif|208px|Tomato paste sterile packed into PET-bags © TAMPA|alt=Tomato paste, sterile packed into PET-bags © TAMPA]]
 
|-
 
|-
| Solar reflector used for tomato processing © TAMPA<br/>
+
| Solar reflector used for tomato processing © TAMPA
| Processing of tomatoes in Tembien © TAMPA<br/>
+
| Processing of tomatoes in Tembien © TAMPA
| Tomato paste sterile packed into PET-bags © TAMPA<br/>
+
| Tomato paste sterile packed into PET-bags © TAMPA
 
|}
 
|}
 
 
<br/>
 
<br/>
  
<br/>
 
  
 
= Quantified Tomato Value Chain =
 
= Quantified Tomato Value Chain =
 
 
The quantified tomato processing value chain design (liquid and dry): [[File:Quantified tomato processing value chain design.png|center|750px|Quantified tomato processing value chain design (liquid and dry)|alt=Quantified tomato processing value chain design (liquid and dry)]]
 
The quantified tomato processing value chain design (liquid and dry): [[File:Quantified tomato processing value chain design.png|center|750px|Quantified tomato processing value chain design (liquid and dry)|alt=Quantified tomato processing value chain design (liquid and dry)]]
  
Line 45: Line 43:
  
 
<br/>
 
<br/>
 +
  
 
= Financial Plan =
 
= Financial Plan =
Line 51: Line 50:
  
 
     Fix costs (= overheads) = 83,943 birr
 
     Fix costs (= overheads) = 83,943 birr
+ Variable costs          = 50,877 birr       
+
+ Variable costs          = 50,877 birr       
 
 
 
'''Total costs = 134,820 birr'''
 
'''Total costs = 134,820 birr'''
  
 
<br/>
 
<br/>
  
== Annual turnover ==
+
 
 +
== Annual Turnover ==
  
 
  ''Liquid tomato products:''
 
  ''Liquid tomato products:''
1,260 bags of paste, 500 g x 25.0 birr = 31,500 birr
+
1,260 bags of paste, 500 g x 25.0 birr = 31,500 birr
3,150 bags of paste, 200 g x 12.0 birr = 37,800 birr
+
3,150 bags of paste, 200 g x 12.0 birr = 37,800 birr
1,470 bottles of juice, 0.5l x 12.0 birr = 17,640 birr
+
1,470 bottles of juice, 0.5l x 12.0 birr = 17,640 birr
''Dry tomato products:''
+
''Dry tomato products:''
3,360 bags of slices, 200 g x 10.5 birr = 35,280 birr
+
3,360 bags of slices, 200 g x 10.5 birr = 35,280 birr
2,520 bags of powder, 30 g x 5.0 birr = 12,600 birr  
+
2,520 bags of powder, 30 g x 5.0 birr = 12,600 birr  
 
 
 
'''Total turnover = 134,820 birr'''
 
'''Total turnover = 134,820 birr'''
  
Line 72: Line 70:
  
  
== Investment costs and depreciation ==
+
== Investment Costs and Depreciation ==
  
{| align="center" style="width: 750px" border="1" cellspacing="1" cellpadding="5"
+
{| align="center" style="width: 750px;" border="1" cellspacing="0" cellpadding="3"
|-
 
| '''Description'''<br/>
 
| '''Purchase prize (ETB)per unit'''<br/>
 
| '''Purchase prize (ETB)total'''<br/>
 
| '''Supplier'''<br/>
 
| '''Depreciation years'''<br/>
 
| '''Depreciation (ETB)/'''a<br/>
 
 
|-
 
|-
| 2 solar panels, 90 Wp<br/>
+
| '''Description'''
| 6,000<br/>
+
| '''Purchase prize (ETB)per unit'''
| 12,000<br/>
+
| '''Purchase prize (ETB)total'''
| LYDETCO 0911207283<br/>
+
| '''Supplier'''
| 20<br/>
+
| '''Depreciation years'''
| 600<br/>
+
| '''Depreciation (ETB)/'''a
 
|-
 
|-
| 1 regulator, 12 V/20A<br/>
+
| 2 solar panels, 90 Wp
| 2,500<br/>
+
| 6,000
| 2,500<br/>
+
| 12,000
| LYDETCO 0911207283<br/>
+
| LYDETCO 0911207283
| 10<br/>
+
| 20
| 250<br/>
+
| 600
 
|-
 
|-
| 2 lorry batteries, 12 V/120 Ah<br/>
+
| 1 regulator, 12 V/20A
| 4,000<br/>
+
| 2,500
| 8,000<br/>
+
| 2,500
| Mekele shops<br/>
+
| LYDETCO 0911207283
| 4<br/>
+
| 10
| 2,000<br/>
+
| 250
 
|-
 
|-
| 1 metal stand for solar panels<br/>
+
| 2 lorry batteries, 12 V/120 Ah
| 2,500<br/>
+
| 4,000
| 2,500<br/>
+
| 8,000
| Sami metal shop Mekele<br/>
+
| Mekele shops
| 20<br/>
+
| 4
| 125<br/>
+
| 2,000
 
|-
 
|-
| 1 wooden/metal box for batteries (60x70x40cm), with metal cover<br/>
+
| 1 metal stand for solar panels
| 1,600<br/>
+
| 2,500
| 1,600<br/>
+
| 2,500
| Carpenter Mekele<br/>
+
| Sami metal shop Mekele
| 10<br/>
+
| 20
| 160<br/>
+
| 125
 
|-
 
|-
| Cables, fuses, switches, sockets<br/>
+
| 1 wooden/metal box for batteries (60x70x40cm), with metal cover
| 1,000<br/>
+
| 1,600
| 1,000<br/>
+
| 1,600
| Mekele shops<br/>
+
| Carpenter Mekele
| 5<br/>
+
| 10
| 200<br/>
+
| 160
 
|-
 
|-
| 1 Inverter, sine 500 W, with switch/fuse<br/>
+
| Cables, fuses, switches, sockets
| 20,000<br/>
+
| 1,000
| 20,000<br/>
+
| 1,000
| LYDETCO 0911207283<br/>
+
| Mekele shops
| 5<br/>
+
| 5
| 4,000<br/>
+
| 200
 
|-
 
|-
| 4 Solar cookers, parabolic dish, SK 14<br/>
+
| 1 Inverter, sine 500 W, with switch/fuse
| 4,500<br/>
+
| 20,000
| 18,000<br/>
+
| 20,000
| Bereket Solar Addis Abeba (0911 225131)<br/>
+
| LYDETCO 0911207283
| 20<br/>
+
| 5
| 900<br/>
+
| 4,000
 
|-
 
|-
| 1 Mixer, 220 V, 200 – 400 W<br/>
+
| 4 Solar cookers, parabolic dish, SK 14
| 1,000<br/>
+
| 4,500
| 1,000<br/>
+
| 18,000
| Mekele shops<br/>
+
| Bereket Solar Addis Abeba (0911 225131)
| 1<br/>
+
| 20
| 1,000<br/>
+
| 900
 
|-
 
|-
| 1 Sealing machine, twin sealing, 220V, 65W<br/>
+
| 1 Mixer, 220 V, 200 – 400 W
| 8,300<br/>
+
| 1,000
| 8,300<br/>
+
| 1,000
| Germany / TAMPA<br/>
+
| Mekele shops
| 10<br/>
+
| 1
| 830<br/>
+
| 1,000
 
|-
 
|-
| 1 Balance, digital, 0 – 5000g<br/>
+
| 1 Sealing machine, twin sealing, 220V, 65W
| 500<br/>
+
| 8,300
| 500<br/>
+
| 8,300
| Addis Abeba shops<br/>
+
| Germany / TAMPA
| 2<br/>
+
| 10
| 250<br/>
+
| 830
 
|-
 
|-
| 1 Balance, analog, 20kg<br/>
+
| 1 Balance, digital, 0 – 5000g
| 500<br/>
+
| 500
| 500<br/>
+
| 500
| Mekele market & shops<br/>
+
| Addis Abeba shops
| 5<br/>
+
| 2
| 100<br/>
+
| 250
 
|-
 
|-
| 1 Balance, analog, 20kg<br/>
+
| 1 Balance, analog, 20kg
| 500<br/>
+
| 500
| 500<br/>
+
| 500
| Mekele market & shops<br/>
+
| Mekele market & shops
| 5<br/>
+
| 5
| 100<br/>
+
| 100
 
|-
 
|-
| 1 Water container with water tap and metal stand, 20 liters for tomato washing<br/>
+
| 1 Water container with water tap and metal stand, 20 liters for tomato washing
| 2,000<br/>
+
| 2,000
| 2,000<br/>
+
| 2,000
| Mekele metal workshops<br/>
+
| Mekele metal workshops
| 10<br/>
+
| 10
| 200<br/>
+
| 200
 
|-
 
|-
| Sieves, spoons, washing pans, baskets<br/>
+
| Sieves, spoons, washing pans, baskets
| 1,000<br/>
+
| 1,000
| 1,000<br/>
+
| 1,000
| Mekele market<br/>
+
| Mekele market
| 2<br/>
+
| 2
| 500<br/>
+
| 500
 
|-
 
|-
| 1 Sterilization kettle, 20 liter<br/>
+
| 1 Sterilization kettle, 20 liter
| 1,500<br/>
+
| 1,500
| 1,500<br/>
+
| 1,500
| Mekele market & shops<br/>
+
| Mekele market & shops
| 10<br/>
+
| 10
| 150<br/>
+
| 150
 
|-
 
|-
| 1 Sterilization thermometer (110°Celsius)<br/>
+
| 1 Sterilization thermometer (110°Celsius)
| 300<br/>
+
| 300
| 300<br/>
+
| 300
| Mekele market & shops<br/>
+
| Mekele market & shops
| 3<br/>
+
| 3
| 100<br/>
+
| 100
 
|-
 
|-
| 1 Working table, 3m x 1m<br/>
+
| 1 Working table, 3m x 1m
| 2,000<br/>
+
| 2,000
| 2,000<br/>
+
| 2,000
| Mekele carpenter<br/>
+
| Mekele carpenter
| 3<br/>
+
| 3
| 100<br/>
+
| 100
 
|-
 
|-
| 1 solar dryer, 5m x 2m<br/>
+
| 1 solar dryer, 5m x 2m
| 15,000<br/>
+
| 15,000
| 15,000<br/>
+
| 15,000
| Mekele metal workshops<br/>
+
| Mekele metal workshops
| 10<br/>
+
| 10
| 1,500<br/>
+
| 1,500
 
|-
 
|-
| '''Total (ETB)'''<br/>
+
| '''Total (ETB)'''
 
| <br/>
 
| <br/>
| '''97,700'''<br/>
+
| '''97,700'''
 
| <br/>
 
| <br/>
 
| <br/>
 
| <br/>
| '''13,065'''<br/>
+
| '''13,065'''
 
|}
 
|}
 +
For more details on the business plan, please see [[Business Plan for Solar Processing of Tomatoes|this article]].
 +
  
For more details on the business plan, please see [[Business Plan for Solar Processing of Tomatoes|this article]].
+
= Further Information<br/> =
  
 +
*<span dir="auto"></span>[[Business Plan for Solar Processing of Tomatoes|Business Plan for Solar Processing of Tomatoes]]<br/>
 +
*[[:File:Flyer TAMPA.pdf|Flyer TAMPA]]<br/>
 +
*[https://www.giz.de/en/worldwide/18912.html GIZ Sustainable land management, Ethiopia]<br/>
 +
*[[Ethiopia Energy Situation|Ethiopia Energy Situation]]<br/>
 +
*[[Small_Scale_Oil_Seeds_Processing|TAMPA project "Small Scale Oil Seeds Processing"]]<br/>
 +
*[[Energy within Food and Agricultural Value Chains|Energy within Food and Agricultural Value Chains]]
 +
*[[PoweringAg Technology Database Source of Energy|PoweringAg Technology Database - Solar Technologies]]
 +
*[[Portal:Water and Energy for Food|Water and Energy for Food (WE4F) portal on energypedia]]
 
<br/>
 
<br/>
  
  
= Further Information =
+
= Reference =
  
*[http://tampa06.en.gongchang.com/about TAMPA]
+
*German Development Cooperation
*[https://www.giz.de/en/worldwide/18912.html GIZ Sustainable land management, Ethiopia]
 
*[[Ethiopia Energy Situation|Ethiopia Energy Situation]]
 
*[[Energy within Food and Agricultural Value Chains|Energy within Food and Agricultural Value Chains]]
 
*[[PoweringAg Technology Database Source of Energy|PoweringAg Technology Database - Solar Technologies]]
 
  
 +
[[Category:Ethiopia]]
 +
[[Category:Powering_Agriculture]]
 +
[[Category:Productive_Use]]
 +
[[Category:Solar]]
 +
[[Category:Solar_Dryers]]
 
[[Category:Financing_Solar]]
 
[[Category:Financing_Solar]]
[[Category:Solar_Dryers]]
 
[[Category:Solar]]
 
[[Category:Productive_Use]]
 
[[Category:Powering_Agriculture]]
 
[[Category:Ethiopia]]
 

Latest revision as of 19:12, 14 July 2020

Economic development in remote rural areas in Ethiopia can be enhanced by value adding on farmers’ agricultural raw products. Small scale agro processing must lead to consumable end products, which are food safe, conservable, transportable and marketable. The following case presents an example of how Solar Energy can support micro and small tomato processing enterprises in Ethiopia. This article is a fact sheet, for more details please see the article Business Plan for Solar Processing of Tomatoes.


Project

TAMPA (Tigray Agricultural Marketing Promotion Agency) started in April 2014 in collaboration with the Sustainable Land Management Program (GIZ SLMP) the promotion of micro and small enterprises for tomato processing using renewable energy. The target groups are cooperatives of tomato farmers producing in remote areas without access to electrical power (2014: only 14% of the Ethiopian population has access to grid power, see also Ethiopia Energy Situation).

Many agro processing steps need both thermic energy (heat) and electrical energy (power), both will be obtained from the sunlight. In Tigray, the availability of solar power is reliable and regular in the dry season. The tomato season starts around end of November and ends in the month of June. Then, the processing period will last for 7 months = 210 days. This climate smart technology helps to reduce post-harvest losses and enhances the tomato farmers to add value on their raw products.

The end products are tomato paste/sauce, tomato juice, dried tomatoes and tomato powder. These are conservable without cooling (paste 6 months, juice 1 month, dried tomatoes/powder up to 1 year) and allow the producers to receive better prices for their commercial products:


  • 3,150 kg of fresh tomatoes are processed to 1,260 kg long conservable tomato paste, packed into 3,150 bags of each 200 gram plus 1,260 bags of 500g
  • 1,050 kg of fresh tomatoes are processed to 735 liter of tomato juice, packed in 1,470 bottles (‘Highland’) of each 0.5 liters
  • 5,000 kg of fresh tomatoes will be sun-dried to 675 kg dried tomato slices, and 75 kg tomato powder, packed into vacuum-sealed polyethylene bags

Please note: The solar system is all year around available and can be used for other income generating activities, like television, video, lighting, battery charging, water cooking, sterilization, other food processing, office services like scan/print/internet/email…


Technology

A room of 16 m2 should be sufficient as processing site. It will be built by the farmers’ men power contribution, stones are available onsite and construction material like cement, metal sheets for the roof and a metal door/window as well as tiles will be supplied by the GIZ SLM Program.

The solar panel will be placed on a metal stand, which allows daily cleaning to maintain its power for battery charging and processing work. Also, the stand allows turning around of the panel, by adjusting the direction, an optimal output from the sunlight may be obtained in case of need.

Special attention will be given to train the processing team in technical aspects of the photovoltaic power system. This includes the handling of the precious inverter, the regular cleaning of the panel and the maintenance of the acid batteries.


Solar reflector used for tomato processing © TAMPA Processing of tomatoes in Tembien © TAMPA Tomato paste, sterile packed into PET-bags © TAMPA
Solar reflector used for tomato processing © TAMPA Processing of tomatoes in Tembien © TAMPA Tomato paste sterile packed into PET-bags © TAMPA



Quantified Tomato Value Chain

The quantified tomato processing value chain design (liquid and dry):

Quantified tomato processing value chain design (liquid and dry)




Financial Plan

Costs

   Fix costs (= overheads) = 83,943 birr

+ Variable costs = 50,877 birr Total costs = 134,820 birr



Annual Turnover

Liquid tomato products:

1,260 bags of paste, 500 g x 25.0 birr = 31,500 birr 3,150 bags of paste, 200 g x 12.0 birr = 37,800 birr 1,470 bottles of juice, 0.5l x 12.0 birr = 17,640 birr Dry tomato products: 3,360 bags of slices, 200 g x 10.5 birr = 35,280 birr 2,520 bags of powder, 30 g x 5.0 birr = 12,600 birr Total turnover = 134,820 birr



Investment Costs and Depreciation

Description Purchase prize (ETB)per unit Purchase prize (ETB)total Supplier Depreciation years Depreciation (ETB)/a
2 solar panels, 90 Wp 6,000 12,000 LYDETCO 0911207283 20 600
1 regulator, 12 V/20A 2,500 2,500 LYDETCO 0911207283 10 250
2 lorry batteries, 12 V/120 Ah 4,000 8,000 Mekele shops 4 2,000
1 metal stand for solar panels 2,500 2,500 Sami metal shop Mekele 20 125
1 wooden/metal box for batteries (60x70x40cm), with metal cover 1,600 1,600 Carpenter Mekele 10 160
Cables, fuses, switches, sockets 1,000 1,000 Mekele shops 5 200
1 Inverter, sine 500 W, with switch/fuse 20,000 20,000 LYDETCO 0911207283 5 4,000
4 Solar cookers, parabolic dish, SK 14 4,500 18,000 Bereket Solar Addis Abeba (0911 225131) 20 900
1 Mixer, 220 V, 200 – 400 W 1,000 1,000 Mekele shops 1 1,000
1 Sealing machine, twin sealing, 220V, 65W 8,300 8,300 Germany / TAMPA 10 830
1 Balance, digital, 0 – 5000g 500 500 Addis Abeba shops 2 250
1 Balance, analog, 20kg 500 500 Mekele market & shops 5 100
1 Water container with water tap and metal stand, 20 liters for tomato washing 2,000 2,000 Mekele metal workshops 10 200
Sieves, spoons, washing pans, baskets 1,000 1,000 Mekele market 2 500
1 Sterilization kettle, 20 liter 1,500 1,500 Mekele market & shops 10 150
1 Sterilization thermometer (110°Celsius) 300 300 Mekele market & shops 3 100
1 Working table, 3m x 1m 2,000 2,000 Mekele carpenter 3 100
1 solar dryer, 5m x 2m 15,000 15,000 Mekele metal workshops 10 1,500
Total (ETB)
97,700

13,065

For more details on the business plan, please see this article.


Further Information



Reference

  • German Development Cooperation